How the Treasury prices items

The netbooks price their items in a dozen different ways, or not at all. A sword that one author values at 15,000 gp might be worth 900 gp in another book. So every item in the Treasury gets a Treasury value worked out by the same rules, for whichever game system you've chosen. Where the netbook states its own price, the original text still shows it.

An item's value has two parts: the thing itself (the steel, the glass, the leather) and its magic.

1. The thing itself: base price

2. The magic: rarity and power

Every magic item gets a rarity that reflects its power, using the same yardstick for every book:

RarityTypical power
CommonMinor conveniences and cantrip-level tricks; no combat bonus
UncommonA +1 bonus, or effects like 1st–3rd level spells, or a few charges of a modest spell
RareA +2 bonus, or effects like 4th–5th level spells, or a +1 item with a strong extra power
Very rareA +3 bonus, or effects like 6th–8th level spells, or a +2 item with strong extra powers
LegendaryA +4 or +5 bonus, 9th level effects, or an item of world-shaking power
ArtifactUnique relics of gods and legends. Priceless: no one sells them

Within its rarity, each item is ranked low, middling or high, which multiplies its magic price by ½, 1 or 2. Intelligent weapons, many powers, or unlimited uses push an item up; drawbacks, few charges and narrow uses push it down. A cursed item is valued as the item it pretends to be, because that is what a buyer would pay.

Consumables (potions, oils, scrolls, a single dose) cost less than permanent items of the same rarity, as the table shows.

Magic price by system (middling power)

RarityOriginal (AD&D)D&D 3.0 / 3.5 / PathfinderD&D 5e5e 2024Pathfinder 2e
Common100 gp250 gp50 gp100 gp30 gp (item 2)
Uncommon750 gp2,000 gp300 gp400 gp160 gp (item 5)
Rare3,000 gp8,000 gp3,000 gp4,000 gp650 gp (item 9)
Very rare15,000 gp32,000 gp30,000 gp40,000 gp2,700 gp (item 13)
Legendary50,000 gp120,000 gp150,000 gp200,000 gp13,500 gp (item 17)
Consumable× ½× ⅒× ½× ½× ⅕

In Pathfinder 2e, low and high power move the item one level down or up instead (× ⅔ or × 1½).

Your campaign

Every world is different, so the Treasury lets you set two things at the top of the page. They are remembered like your game system. Medium / Medium gives the standard values above.

SettingLowMediumHigh
Magic: how common magic items are. This scales only the magic part of a price, so a plain sword costs the same everywhere.× 4: scarce, rarely for sale× 1× ½: plentiful, traded openly
Gold: how much coin is about. This scales the whole price, mundane goods included.× ½: coin is scarce× 1× 2: coin is plentiful and prices inflate

Value in your campaign = (base price + magic price × magic setting) × gold setting, rounded the same way.

Treasury value, step by step

Value = base price + (magic price for its rarity × power × consumable discount), rounded to a tidy figure.

For example, take a +1 longsword with a modest extra power, which is rare and low power. In D&D 5e it's worth 15 gp + 3,000 × ½ = 1,515 gp, rounded to 1,500 gp.