Sword of Dreamless Nights
Magic weapon from Gallery of Magical Blades
By William O. Nielsen
How about a +2 sword (yes, that is a plus) however, for every day that the sword is used it causes the person to have bad dreams when they sleep and not enter REM sleep. This of course (over a period of time which I think is about a week or so) causes the person to be driven insane. This is more of a biological thing and some DM's may not be ready to bring in such things but it is true that if humans (in REAL life) do not dream every night over a long period of time, then they will eventually go mad.