Daemon Firebee's Blade
We once used a weapon that belonged to a man named Daemon Firebee. It was a small sword to the point of being a long dagger. When the person used this, he would begin losing subtle things. I first got a hold of it when I saw my friend disappear over a ridge in the claws of a gargoyle. So I thought. It turned out, my friend had turned into a type of gargoyle and had actually take a virgin boy from the village to Queen Myteroria (our name for the supreme evil). I started using this weapon to "avenge" my friend and seek him out. With every battle, a new power was discovered. My DM was quite good actually. I never realized that all those golden opportunities to get XP and gold were warped. I was seeing the events as he wanted me to see them and slowly changing into a dragon-man. At first it was explained to me that I was growing stronger with the blade.
I was tanning because of the sun and wearing less do to the heat. To show you a bit of what i mean by warped, here's a typical sight for me. While wondering with the rest of the group, you feel a strong inclination to answer Mother Nature's call. While relieving yourself, you see a large man in blue tying a small girl to a tree. He unsheathes his sword and places at the middle of the tattered dress the young black. He removes the right strap and pulls it down her arm revealing a nasty scar. He then reaches to the front of his robe and you can see no more of his hand as his back is to you.
At this, I lunged after the man and split him in two with this magical blade. It shown brightly as I cut the girl form the tree, so I thought the Blade was proud of the Noble deed I had performed. The girl explained she was a magic user but would not tell me why she had been tied up. She promised me the gift of flight within two days and disappeared. The next day I had grown wings from my back and Thought i had been made an angel, or at least a demi-god for the wonderful deeds I had been doing.
In reality, the man in blue was a bounty hunter who had finally caught the Wicked Witch of the West (corny, I know) and I had unleashed this badion. The wings were simply the next step in the conversion and the witch, being one of the more powerful and old demons, recognized it. The truth was displayed before me and I finally discovered a problem when the DM added that I felt no remorse for the valiant knight.
Just a suggestion, but if you do decide to have a Long dagger of morphing, make it as addictive as crack and as subtle as a summer breeze. Let the fights spew forth from unsavory bad guys (who happen to be guardsmen, bounty hunters, knights, paladins, etc.) and give the possessor little choice but to fight. Explain to the group the subtle difference they see in the other as fatigue, exhaustion, drug use, etc. Let the player feel he is in control while modifying and adjusting everything to fit you. After the third use, outward signs should appear. By then, let some of the people know what is really going on through legend, gossip, or flat out black in white (a history book).After the seventh time using it, it should be obvious to all but the player (send him out of the room, call the others at home) but it should also have firm grasp on him. If you wish, the curse was broken by a Paladin, Cleric, and Wizard in our game. We also had the blade heated for removing symbols by a blacksmith. The alignment might not return all the way but the player should still be allowed choice. Incidentally, if you go about removing the curse while the player is asleep (so he won't put up a fight) make sure he is not satisfied with just victory once he gets into another fight. The dagger will no longer reward him with adrenaline and Magic.